Skip to main content

Genius Hour Reflections

We just wrapped up Genius Hour in my seventh grade English class, and there is much to say about that adventure.

The Good Stuff
Even if I felt like a failure most of the time, there were a lot of good things that came from Genius Hour. 
  • Overall, the students said they loved being able to pick what they learned about.
  • During Genius Hour, the majority of students were engaged in their project. 
  • There were some really great presentations and reflections from my students.
  • I had a few parents thank me for doing Genius Hour because it got their kid working on an interest outside of school.
  • There was a good variety of projects and very few cookie cutter projects.
  • Two students who were initially hesitant to do anything were able to get past their fear of failing and had unique projects.
  • Halfway through the process, I started having students write down a goal at the beginning of Genius Hour and had them reflect on it at the end of class.  This help create a stronger purpose for the time.
The Not Good Stuff
Anytime you try something new, you immediately get smacked with a dose of cold reality.  Here's what we struggled with.
  • Many students commented that they did not like having to blog about their project. 
  • The process was too long.
  • We spent too little time prepping and practicing for final presentations.
  • Some students did not communicate their projects clearly to their parents which lead to frustration and confusion.
  • Once one student wanted to do a Minecraft project, it spread and probably limited the creativity of some students.
  • Some students were more stressed about creating a product than the process of learning.
  • The blog was not an efficient way to keep track of student progress.
  • Genius Hour interrupts the flow and momentum of a unit.
Moving Forward
So, in light of all that, Genius Hour will look a lot different next year.  It's time to learn from my mistakes and move forward with a better approach for next time. 

  • I will provide more constraints and structure at the beginning to get them started. 
  • I will find specific ways to adapt/scaffold the project for students with special needs.
  • I will involve students in the grading process by using more self and peer assessment.
  • Rather than an extended project, I will try shorter "bursts" of Genius Hour (work on it for a month and then present vs. work for one trimester). Too much doubt starts to settle in when you wait too long to share. 
  • I will do a better job communicating with parents about projects.
  • I will find better and different ways for students to report their progress without losing essential writing skills practice. 
  • I will model the process better and find better student examples.
  • I will better seize the opportunity to use Genius Hour to teach speaking and active listening skills.
  • I will allow students to work with partners.
If you haven't tried Genius Hour (or something similar), I still recommend it even with all the issues we encountered. I learned a lot through the process about student motivation and autonomy.  There's that magical balance between student choice and teacher control that Genius Hour allows you to experiment with.  

If you have tried Genius Hour, let me know what worked for you!  For now, I will enjoy a break from Genius Hour. :)

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Perception vs. Reality

Before I became a "real" teacher, my perception of teaching English was that I would be blowing kids' minds with classic literature and handing out grammar worksheets.  Needless to say, that hasn't happened...yet. Instead, I was surprised to find that I loved teaching about writing. In particular, I found a love of teaching argumentation and persuasion. The seventh graders are gearing up for argumentative writing. We begin by talking about the concepts of perception and reality and how those two things influence our views of the world and all its issues. I have them make a poster that's based off a popular meme to help ground those concepts. It hardly seems like work, and it's one of the few assignments we do where I get to hear things like, "Can I finish this at home?" or "Can I do another one?" The task is to make a perception and reality poster. I start by showing them an example for a teacher, like this one . This makes for a great ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Tongue Twisters, Growth Mindset, and Self-Portraits

To celebrate the beginning of fall (or to mourn the end of summer), here is a lovely picture of a sunflower in my yard. Here’s what we were up to this week! The seventh graders continued their exploration on narratives this week.   We practiced summary writing and writing about theme.   We also talked about how setting can influence the events of a story.   We used close reading strategies using the Collections Close Reader .   To put all this practice together, my students have some interesting short stories of their own in the works.   I can’t wait to read them! I’m really kicking myself for not getting any pictures of the demonstration speeches we did in second hour this week.   I’ll leave it up to you to picture my students teaching the class how to make cheesecake, wash a dog, tie a bowtie, ride motorcycles, and make lava lamps.   It was a diverse set of topics to say the least. Friday, we relaxed a bit from the stress of speech deli...
Post a Comment
Read more

Dear Middle Schooler

Dear Middle Schooler, I see you on your hard days. I see that zit forming on the center of your face, looking at me like headlights set on high beams. I see those pants that have gotten just a little too short because you grew three inches overnight. I see that your best friend suddenly decided to ignore you for no apparent reason. I see that your parents are going through a divorce and you can’t possibly imagine how you will make it through the day, let alone first hour. I see you, and I know it’s hard. If you polled the entire universe (aliens and all), and asked them what age they wished they could go back to--not a single solitary soul would say twelve. Not. A. Single. One. Because being twelve is like getting a sweaty hug while being kicked in the shins. Being a middle schooler is like lying in the middle of the road and getting run over by a steamroller, and then being scraped off the road and put on the schoolbus because you still have to go to school (Flat Stanley s...
Post a Comment
Read more